The First Wall

Enjoyed this one so much. All the side stories of the normal people that make up Terra makes the world so rich. Some times when it is just all Uber space marines it's gets a little dry. Can't wait for the next one.

After the second book, I hoped the series had finally hit it's stride. Instead we get this jaw-droppingly boring monstrosity full to the brim with filler and little to no action. I stuck to it as much as I could, but I gave up shortly into the second part. The plot never goes anywhere. The characters are never developed. NOTHING HAPPENS!!! GW/BL really messed up when they decided to break the siege of Terra into so many books. There just isn't enough plot/content to do it.

Jonathan Keeble delivers yet another amazing performance qnd brings all characters to life with passion. I loved this book.

Some people complain about the story of the imperial soldiers. It does have an unusual payoff, but it makes sense for the theme. Listen to this book for some good Primarch moments, more on the beginnings the imperial cult, and to gain insight to the timeline of the ground siege.All together its good. Not one of the top books, but I can't recommend skipping it.

It may be to late to pull him, as he wrote this book and the next unreleased one. This one did nothing but reduce the amount of enjoyable books in the series. I hoped the siege series would have been reserved for the A++ writers but McNeil and Thorpe found their way in and underdelivered. Excellent narration. I have listened to all of the other siege books twice. This and fury of magnus or regretfully meh.

Ya blew it, Gav. We get it, your best work is comedy and intrigue, but this key event deserved better. Found my attention wandering until Keeble starts making the old man voice again. Zenobody couldn't carry the story if it were printed on a battle standard.

This was a great book, and a good continue from the first two of the Siege of Terra!

hate to say anything bad about it, but this definitely was not one of my favorites. Story jumped around too much and they added in too much filler. I found myself skipping certain parts. There were some accents Keeble should not do.Overall book was ok and not what I expected.

love most horus harrasy books this one is just boring. alot of story lines that just suck and are not intresting. worst book in series in my opinion.

could not finish. 140 pages are dedicated to a concscript riding a train. a side story with no payoff whatsoever. a major stain on the siege of terra series. although im sure the rest will be as great as the first two. just a symptomof a weak author attempting to stand alongside giants like wright and bowden